Crit responsibly

The intense gaze of a pissed-off, non-sparkly vampire
Don’t make me give you…the look.

OOh I dislike getting a critique that says:
“I don’t read Fantasy. I don’t care for these characters, but people who read Fantasy might like them.”

Totally ok if you don’t like the characters, but WHY? How can I fix it? What was missing? The whole *shrug*, I don’t have to try to provide a useful crit because it’s not my genre is…irksome.

Characters are characters, no matter the genre. They ALL need realistic motivations and behaviors. Grr. But, this is the website where I get to rate my critiquer. Guess who got a low score and a very careful explanation why?