I’ve been doing critiques of some writing on Review Fuse. You do four reviews and get three in return (or, if you pay to join, you get 3 reviews for doing two). The reviews break down the components into individually ranked topics- like dialog, mechanics, plot, characters, etc. You get a star rating and there is room for comments and the ability to add in-line comments.
It’s nice because you rate your reviewers too, and supposedly, you end up being matched with people who review at your level. But since I’m new, I don’t have much track record. It is a bit disconcerting to spend over an hour writing a thorough review, with lots of in-line comments, to get back twenty words: Good characters. (rated 7/10) ; There are places that are known. (7/10); I don’t see any errors (7/10); etc. And still have no idea why I only got 7/10, when no problems were identified. huh.
I do hope I start getting reviews from some of the better ranked reviewers.